Best Restaurants in Little Italy Toronto: Nestled along the vibrant stretch of College Street (between Bathurst and Ossington) in Toronto, Little Italy brings together old-school Italian charm and modern dining innovation. Historically anchored by Italian-Canadian families and eateries, the neighbourhood now blends traditional trattorias, wood-fired pizzerias, tapas bars and daring fusion kitchens. What that means for you: plenty of excellent food choices, each with its own flavour and vibe.
Here are six standout restaurants worth your time—some rooted in heritage, others pushing flavour boundaries. Whether you’re after casual pizza, upscale dinner, or a lively tapas bar, this list has you covered.
1. Café Diplomatico – A Neighbourhood Classic
Why go: Operating for decades, Café Diplomatico is a beloved Little Italy institution—perfect for a relaxed meal, coffee or gelato.
What to order: A classic pasta (e.g., penne alla vodka), an Italian-style espresso, or a proscuitto panini on the patio.
Setting: Easy-going, ideal for brunch or a longer dinner. Grab an outdoor seat and soak in the neighbourhood energy.
2. Bar Raval – Tapas & Craft Cocktails in Style
Why go: Designed as a homage to Barcelona, Bar Raval features a curved mahogany bar and lively vibe—it’s one of Toronto’s most talked-about spots.
What to order: Pintxos (e.g., pan con tomate, grilled octopus), share plates, and a sherry-based cocktail.
Setting: Trendy and energetic—great for dinner and drinks. Arrive early or be prepared to wait for a table.
3. Trattoria Taverniti – Wood-Fired Pizza & Homemade Pasta
Why go: For an authentic Italian dining experience with hearty dishes and a cozy atmosphere, Trattoria Taverniti hits the mark.
What to order: Wood-fired pizza (margherita or more adventurous topping combos) or house-made tagliatelle with rich sauce.
Setting: Family-friendly yet warm; ideal for date nights or a comforting dinner.
4. Contrada – Modern Italian Innovation
Why go: This restaurant brings a refined, chef-driven take to Italian dining—great if you’re looking for something above the standard trattoria.
What to order: Seasonal tasting menu (if available), inventive pasta dishes, excellent cocktails.
Setting: Sleek, upscale and perfect for a special evening out.
5. Campechano Little Italy Location – Even Pizza Neapolitan Needs a Break
Why go: While not Italian per se, this Latin-influenced spot proves how Little Italy has diversified. It’s a crowd-pleaser and adds variety.
What to order: Tacos made in house tortillas, craft beer or mezcal cocktail.
Setting: Casual, lively and ideal for groups or something a little different.
6. A3 Napoli – Napolitana Style, Big Flavour
Why go: For those who believe pizza is life, A3 Napoli serves Napoli-style pies in an inviting Little Italy setting.
What to order: Thin-crust Neapolitan pizza (look for the blistered crust), paired with a good Italian red or craft beer.
Setting: Relaxed and fun—perfect for a casual dinner or post-event meal.
Planning Your Visit: Tips & Context
When to go:
- Evenings are lively—patios come alive in warm months.
- Weekday evenings can be less hectic; weekends tend to fill up fast.
Reservations:
- For places like Contrada or Bar Raval try booking ahead (especially dinner).
- For the more casual spots, arriving early or snagging a sidewalk table works well.
Vibe & Neighbourhood:
- Little Italy is much more than pizza: it’s a blend of cafés, bars, old-school bakeries, and new restaurants.
- Explore before/after dinner – College Street is pedestrian-friendly and full of energy.
Mix your staples and surprises:
- You’ll find classic Italian dining, but the district also welcomes global influences. Want something different? Consider the non-Italian spots too for a change of pace.
City tips:
- Take the TTC (streetcar along College) or plan for parking on side streets.
- Ask about daily specials, especially in spring & summer when local produce shines.
- Dress smart-casual if you’re heading to upscale dining; comfy but tidy works for casual spots.
Final Thoughts
Little Italy Toronto blends heritage and innovation in a way that delights food-lovers. Whether you’re after the comforting familiarity of a family-run trattoria, the buzzing energy of a tapas bar or the precision of a modern Italian kitchen, this neighbourhood delivers. Each of the six restaurants above brings something distinct—and memorable—to the table. So wander down College Street, pick a place that matches your mood, and get ready for a delicious evening.